Twice Baked Potatoes

Keltin

New member
Gold Site Supporter
Here is my rendition of twice baked potatoes. This is really more of a “how-to” than a hard set recipe. Pics are at the bottom.

Twice Baked Potatoes

Ingredients

2 Large Baking Potatoes
Milk
Butter
Salt & Pepper

Optional Ingredients

Bacon or Bacon Bits
Cheese
Green Onions
Anything else you like!

Preparation

Start by baking the potatoes till done. You can do this in a regular oven or use your microwave for faster cooking. Once the potatoes are done, allow them to cool until you can handle them.

Start by cutting out the top. You’ll want to use a medium sized knife and pierce the potato at a 45 degree angle. Cut all the way around the potato to make your opening. Once you have cut all the way around, lift the top off.

Now score the potato flesh length wise several times. Next, score the flesh across the middle the entire length of the potato. This forms a cross hatch bit of scoring.

Once scored, use a spoon to scoop the flesh out of the potato to a large mixing bowl. As you are scooping the flesh out, be sure to turn the spoon so that the back is to the wall of the potato thus allowing the concave side to “cut” and shear away the flesh. Don’t scoop too deep on the floor or walls. You want to leave just less than 1/4 inch of flesh.

Once the flesh is out of the shell, grab the top you cut off and bend it in half to break it and then easily peel the skin away from that flesh.

Repeat the scoring and scooping process for the next potato; as well as making sure to get the flesh from the top you cut out. Once all the flesh is in the large mixing bowl, you’ll basically make mashed potatoes. Add enough butter and milk in a 40/60 ratio to moisten the potatoes into a firm and consistent mash. Add salt and pepper to taste as well as any other ingredients you like.

Using a spoon, transfer the mashed flesh back into the hollowed out potato shells. Make sure to carefully pack it into all crevices and corners as you fill it. Once filled, the flesh will be taller than before and will poke out of the top of the shell. Smooth and swirl with a fork to give the tops some edges and swirls. These brown nicely when you bake them again.

At this point, you can let the potatoes rest in the fridge for a few hours. When ready, back the potatoes in a 400 to 450 degree oven until warmed through and nicely browned on top. Add cheese if you wish.

Here is a pictorial.

1. Start with a large fully cooked potato.
2i0pvea.jpg


2. Begin cutting out the top.
2qs4i2f.jpg


3. Once the top is cut out, lift it off.
v33yv6.jpg


4. Set the top aside.
25a1y0o.jpg


5. Score the potato length wise.
9vian8.jpg


6. Score the potato cross wise.
11v44du.jpg


7. Scoop the scored flesh out with a spoon.
23uwtpj.jpg


8. Turn the spoon as you scoop the walls to easily “cut” away the flesh.
33kr8k6.jpg


9. Break the top in half and peel the skin from that flesh.
28588y.jpg


10. Both shells are now ready.
1042g6d.jpg


11. Mash the flesh with butter and milk to make consistent and a bit firm. Add your favorite ingredients and mix well.
2nkj5ms.jpg


12. Use the spoon to fill the potatoes with the mashed flesh. Start at one end and work your way to the other.
m7dtew.jpg
 
Last edited:

Keltin

New member
Gold Site Supporter
Wrapping it up......

13. Once filled, “fluff” the top with a fork to give it some texture that will brown.
34dijr5.jpg


14. Bake until warmed through and brown on top.

m75o1y.jpg
 
Last edited:

Keltin

New member
Gold Site Supporter
Hubby loves a twiced baked tater! Thank you! OH, and bacon is not optinal!

Agreed! :yum:

I actually used Bacon Bits tonight. I was out of Chives and green onions or they would have gone in there as well.
 

Fisher's Mom

Mother Superior
Super Site Supporter
Wow, those look fantastic, Keltin! Your tutorial made clear what I did wrong the one time I made these. I cut the potatoes exactly in half, but then I had a problem stuffing them and having it stay in the "shell". Duh! Thank you for taking the time to take pics and post them - you've just helped me add another thing to my list of foods I can cook. (And btw, it looks like you are really great with your hands.:brows:)
 

buckytom

Grill Master
those do look good.

keltin, have you ever baked the skins first, before stuffing them? they get really crispy. but then i guess they'd be thrice baked spuds.
 

Keltin

New member
Gold Site Supporter
those do look good.

keltin, have you ever baked the skins first, before stuffing them? they get really crispy. but then i guess they'd be thrice baked spuds.

No, I never tried that. How interesting. I'll have to try that! Thanks!
 

Keltin

New member
Gold Site Supporter
Wow, those look fantastic, Keltin! Your tutorial made clear what I did wrong the one time I made these. I cut the potatoes exactly in half, but then I had a problem stuffing them and having it stay in the "shell". Duh! Thank you for taking the time to take pics and post them - you've just helped me add another thing to my list of foods I can cook. (And btw, it looks like you are really great with your hands.:brows:)


Fantastic! I hope you try these. They really are rather easy to do. :clap:

"And btw, it looks like you are really great with your hands" :blink::whistling:
 
Last edited:

Miniman

Mini man - maxi food
Gold Site Supporter
I use sour cream instead of milk. I get the year 7s to make them at school - it is one of the top dishes.
 

homecook

New member
Those do look good, I've been known to add shrimp, lobster or crab also. It then becomes a main meal with a little cheese sauce!

Barb
 

JoeV

Dough Boy
Site Supporter
Like Chowhound, I cut mine in half, mainly because my older friends often don't want a whole potato. If you have good eaters, your method is definitely a nicer way to present the whole potato.
 

Keltin

New member
Gold Site Supporter
Those do look good, I've been known to add shrimp, lobster or crab also. It then becomes a main meal with a little cheese sauce!

Barb

There’s a BBQ shack here in town that serves “loaded” potatoes. They add all kinds of stuff, primarily your choice of meat….smoked chicken, beef, or pork. They are HUGE, and definitely a main dish. One loaded potato and a salad is a meal. The potatoes I did last night were really big, and we ended up just sharing the largest one, so I have one more to cook tonight. :biggrin:
 

sattie

Resident Rocker Lady
Looks great Keltin, I don't think I have ever had a fresh made twice baked tater... It sounds wonderful and looks great!
 

babe

New member
yummy, and really good when cooking for one. will do it your way. for me it is a meal with a salad.
 
This is a very nice post. It shows that even seemingly simple dishes have a method that if adhered to will make it all work so much better. I never much thought of it (also never made them) but your method is very clear and logical. They do look very good. I think I will try them soon. Thanks for posting.
 
Top